top of page

Carlisle Inn is the 2023 Award Winner as Best Business Hotel, Presented by Travelers Atlas®.

3727 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota - Florida 34232-2409 - USA


Discover an inviting slice of mid-western Amish and Mennonite charm in sunny Sarasota at our distinguished establishment, hailed as the Best Hotel in Sarasota. Our spacious rooms seamlessly blend modern comfort with timeless allure, all while being just a stone's throw away from the renowned Siesta and Lido Key beaches. Unwind by the inviting outdoor pool, marvel at our meticulously crafted decor, and wake up to a delightful complimentary breakfast. With a steadfast focus on cleanliness and family-friendliness, our luxurious suites provide a welcoming and home-like retreat.

Savor serenity in the heart of Sarasota, where Amish-inspired tranquility beckons. Our expansive rooms seamlessly marry contemporary comforts with time-honored traditions, offering a retreat just moments from Siesta and Lido Key beaches. Bask in the outdoor pool's allure, revel in our thoughtfully curated decor, and start your day with a complimentary breakfast. Amid a family-friendly environment, our lavish suites become your personal haven.

Experience the allure of mid-western Amish charm nestled in Sarasota's vibrant heart. Our spacious rooms marry modern amenities with classic charm, conveniently located near Siesta and Lido Key beaches. Rejuvenate by the outdoor pool, admire our carefully curated decor, and relish a complimentary breakfast. With a focus on cleanliness and family comfort, our lavish suites offer a home away from home.







Work Friendly




3727 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota - Florida 34232-2409 - USA


(941) 296-1343


SUN Open 24 hours

MON Open 24 hours

TUE Open 24 hours

WED Open 24 hours

THU Open 24 hours

FRI Open 24 hours

SAT Open 24 hours



We stayed here for one evening and this hotel is a Gem . The premises is a beautiful sight, the hotel is extremely clean, the rooms are big, specious and there is attention to all details in decor


Being an Business Owner of a Cleaning Company I must say, job well done. This was the best and cleanist stay I have ever stayed in. From checking in to checking out. Very welcoming, very very clean and staff was amazing.


Excellent in every way. The minute we walked into the lobby we were warmly greeted by the staff at the front desk. The vibe is a clean modern spacious hotel.



Julia M
Wow, what a great place! Very clean and cozy. Within 10-15 min from great beaches and downtown Sarasota without noise and insane charges per stay. Breakfast was very good as well. Highly recommend!


Absolutely underrated. Place is very nice. Breakfast is nice. This hotel is probably the nicest place we’ve stayed. You’d think it’s a 4 star hotel. Staff very friendly. Great location, only a couple miles from Siesta key beach


Lucie M
We loved our stay at the Carlisle. The room was large and extremely clean and quiet. No noisy AC! We'll be back for sure to explore more of the area. Great hot breakfast and cookies in the afternoon. Very homey. I loved the quilt samplers displayed on the walls.



Aimee G.
If I could give this hotel 10 stars I would. Peace and comfort is their motto and they deliver.
Staff, comfort, 84° pool, cleanliness, friendliness.


Shel G.
The Carlisle Hotel is an absolute treasure if you're planning to visit Sarasota. There is so much character and charm in this Amish inn. The rooms are spacious and comfortable, and the hallways are wide with comfortable furniture.


Julian n.
The Carlisle Inn was a great stay in Sarasota and we will return. The staff was extremely friendly and went out of their way to greet us and ensure we had a good stay.

bottom of page