top of page

Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza is the 2023 Award Winner as Best Pizza in Staten Island, Presented by Travelers' Atlas®.

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island - New York 10308 - USA

Restaurants

In Staten Island, Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza has gained attention for its unique pizza-making style. In its first year, its Vodka Pizza was named America’s Best Pizza and later, it was recognized as the Best Pizza in Staten Island by Travelers Atlas. The pizzeria has received considerable media coverage in newspapers, magazines, and TV broadcasts. It has attracted political figures, celebrities, and local residents.

The success of the pizzeria is attributed to its focus on quality ingredients, including Italian-imported San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and extra virgin olive oil. Its wood-fired brick oven, reaching 800 degrees, gives the pizzas a flavor akin to traditional Italian styles. Besides pizza, the establishment offers a varied Italian menu, a wine list, house-made sangria, and a selection of bar drinks, making it a well-rounded dining option in Staten Island.

Ratings

tripadvisor-logo-5.png

4.5

pngwing.com.png

4.6

Recognitions

spa.png

Local's Favorite

spa.png

Innovative

Contact

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island - New York 10308

Website 

+1 (718) 987-2422

Hours

SUN 12 PM - 10 PM

MON 11:30 AM - 10 PM

TUE 11:30 AM - 10 PM

WED 11:30 AM - 10 PM

THU 11:30 AM - 10 PM

FRI 11:30 AM - 10 PM

SAT 12 AM - 11 PM

Reviews

3.png
1.png

Rosemarie A
Absolutely delicious and great service
Lea was excellent. She was so knowledgeable about the menu. Our bartender Javier was great! Try the cucumber refresher! We loved the vidka pie and linguini with clams!

1.png

NYNJexperience
Came with a larger group of friends. Had some drinks at the bar (large, full bar with many options) Everything was amazing, appetizers, the pork chop infused with duck fat was so good! And we had several pizzas.

1.png

Samuel B
The pizza was phenomenal cooked to perfection and the 4 cheese rigatoni was amazing I would highly recommend coming here any day of the week.

Reviews

1.png

Melissa Lazzara
The food was delicious, from apps through dessert. The pizza, the pasta was all amazing! Must save room for the apple pie pizza alla mode. The service was top notch. Our server Lea was so friendly, so attentive and just the sweetest.

1.png

J B
Great place, good food, bar is beautiful. Our waitress, Sophia, was fantastic. Scot, the owner, was very attentive and welcoming. Most notably, the entire staff from the bar tender to the bus attendants were all so friendly. Will definitely return.

1.png

Analia Gerard
Walked in Great Kills on this beautiful day to check out the new location of Goodfellas. The place is just lovely, with a pristine bar, loft VIP section and side with many tables facing the brick oven. The modern feel is very welcoming.

Reviews

1.png

Linda P.
Best item on menu is the vodka pie hands down. They make it different from any other place I've had it. Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto peas and the sauce !!!

1.png

Leoanrdo G.
Amazing pizza and amazing service
We order the pizza Quattro Gusti with Prosciutto also a pizza with Porcini & Arugula , spectacular, cooked to perfection and excellent flavor

1.png

Mark C.
We moved to the island a few years ago and were told how good the pizza was here, but no place lived up to the hype.

bottom of page