top of page

What the Fish is the 2023 Award Winner as Best Seafood Place, Presented by Travelers Atlas®.

921 Truman Ave, Key West - Florida 33040 -USA


Emerging seemingly out of thin air and gracing your plate with culinary wonders, What The Fish Rolls & More presents a delectable narrative that centers around ocean-to-table delights. As the distinguished recipient of the Ocean-to-Table Excellence Award for offering the Best Seafood in Key West, our focus revolves around locally sourced, freshly caught treasures from the deep blue sea. We're passionate about crafting dishes that embody the essence of the ocean, offering an array of seasonal favorites such as succulent crab cakes and indulgent lobster rolls. Moreover, our menu boasts an enticing assortment of seafood-infused buns and a captivating selection of ready-to-enjoy entrées, providing an unforgettable dining experience that's nothing short of extraordinary. Dive into our story and savor the ocean's bounty like never before.

Emerging seemingly out of nowhere and landing on your plate, What The Fish Rolls & More presents a unique culinary tale. Our passion lies in transforming freshly caught ocean treasures into unforgettable gastronomic experiences. With a focus on locally sourced ingredients, we offer an array of seasonal delights, from succulent crab cakes to indulgent lobster rolls. Our diverse selection of buns and ready-to-enjoy dishes reflects the essence of the sea and provides a feast of flavors for every palate. Explore our story and let the flavors of the ocean engulf your senses.

From the deep blue directly onto your plate, the culinary story of What The Fish Rolls & More unfolds. With a focus on the freshness of ingredients sourced directly from the ocean, we offer a unique and unforgettable gastronomic experience. From succulent crab cakes to indulgent lobster rolls, our seasonal dishes celebrate the bounty of the sea. Our selection of seafood-infused buns and the variety of ready-to-enjoy dishes complement the menu irresistibly. We invite you to explore our narrative and savor the flavors of the ocean like never before.







Exotic Flavours




921 Truman Ave, Key West - Florida 33040-USA




SUN 6 PM - 10 PM

MON 6 PM - 10 PM

TUE Closed

WED 6 PM - 10 PM

THU 6 PM - 10 PM

FRI 6 PM - 10 PM

SAT 6 PM - 10 PM



Can't recommend enough
Amazing food. Super fresh. Owner was a throw back to the days when owners cared. Super friendly and engaging.


My husband and I decided to eat lunch here after reading all of the great reviews and not to mention it was just a few steps away from where we were staying.


For fresh fish, this restaurant does not disappoint. I had the mahi mahi ceviche, which is raw. My son had a fried mahi mahi sandwich. Both were fantastic.



Julita Smith
The food was very delicious, we tried the banana chicken and the Thai curry swordfish, both were amazing. The key lime pie could of used a bit more lime in it but otherwise it was very creamy and delicious.


Morgan Conners
We brought our party of 4 here for a change from the food around Duval street and were not disappointed. We had great food and great service. The key lime pie cocktail is delicious. We started with the tropical salsa which was very good, it reminded me a little of ceviche.


Joan B
Have been stopping here every year for at least 20 years. Love the food and the new spot is just beautiful. Tonight I had 3 cheese Caesar salad and one of my favorites, their meat loaf. The key lime pie dessert is also delicious.



Mel C.
Wow. Fresh Mahi today. Conch fritters were yummy but the ceviche Del Mar was the star. Delicious! Great service friendly staff great views of canal and boats going by. Highly recommend!


Nina U.
The service was spectacular. Enrique is sooooo nice and accommodating. I couldn't have asked for a better service from the time you enter to the time you leave, he ensures you have what you need and are well taken care of.


Miriam C.
Great food, super friendly staff
Will be coming back
The calamari salad delicious

bottom of page